[{"data":1,"prerenderedAt":1670},["ShallowReactive",2],{"navigation":3,"\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fagentic-coding-engineer-skills":357,"\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fagentic-coding-engineer-skills-surround":782},[4,8,17,21,25,29,33,345,349,353],{"title":5,"path":6,"stem":7},"About","\u002Fabout","about",{"title":9,"path":10,"stem":11,"children":12},"Authentication","\u002Fauth","auth",[13],{"title":14,"path":15,"stem":16},"Email Confirmation","\u002Fauth\u002Fconfirmation","auth\u002Fconfirmation",{"title":18,"path":19,"stem":20},"Industry Briefs","\u002Fcase-studies","case-studies",{"title":22,"path":23,"stem":24},"Contact","\u002Fcontact","contact",{"title":26,"path":27,"stem":28},"Thinkata | Production AI Engineering","\u002F","index",{"title":30,"path":31,"stem":32},"Insights","\u002Finsights","insights",{"title":34,"path":35,"stem":36,"children":37},"News","\u002Fnews","news",[38,41,65],{"title":39,"path":35,"stem":40},"News & Insights","news\u002Findex",{"title":18,"path":42,"stem":43,"children":44},"\u002Fnews\u002Fcase-studies","news\u002Fcase-studies",[45,49,53,57,61],{"title":46,"path":47,"stem":48},"Building Secure and Scalable AI Infrastructure: Integrating with Existing Systems through Modern Cloud Frameworks","\u002Fnews\u002Fcase-studies\u002Fcloud-infrastructure-ai","news\u002Fcase-studies\u002Fcloud-infrastructure-ai",{"title":50,"path":51,"stem":52},"Making Sense of Financial Regulations: How AI Teams Can Tackle Complex Documents","\u002Fnews\u002Fcase-studies\u002Ffinancial-regulations","news\u002Fcase-studies\u002Ffinancial-regulations",{"title":54,"path":55,"stem":56},"AI-Powered Transformations in Healthcare","\u002Fnews\u002Fcase-studies\u002Fhealth-care","news\u002Fcase-studies\u002Fhealth-care",{"title":58,"path":59,"stem":60},"Generative AI in Upstream Natural Gas: Shell's Exploration Initiative","\u002Fnews\u002Fcase-studies\u002Foil-gas","news\u002Fcase-studies\u002Foil-gas",{"title":62,"path":63,"stem":64},"Optimizing Manufacturing with AI-Driven Multi-Agent Systems","\u002Fnews\u002Fcase-studies\u002Fsupply-chain-optimization","news\u002Fcase-studies\u002Fsupply-chain-optimization",{"title":30,"path":66,"stem":67,"children":68},"\u002Fnews\u002Finsights","news\u002Finsights",[69,73,77,81,85,89,93,97,101,105,109,113,117,121,125,129,133,137,141,145,149,153,157,161,165,169,173,177,181,185,189,193,197,201,205,209,213,217,221,225,229,233,237,241,245,249,253,257,261,265,269,273,277,281,285,289,293,297,301,305,309,313,317,321,325,329,333,337,341],{"title":70,"path":71,"stem":72},"Nothing Gets Deleted, Just Blurred","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fadaptive-context-memory","news\u002Finsights\u002Fadaptive-context-memory",{"title":74,"path":75,"stem":76},"The Capability-Reliability Split in Agent Systems","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fagent-capability-reliability-split","news\u002Finsights\u002Fagent-capability-reliability-split",{"title":78,"path":79,"stem":80},"When Code Gets Cheap, Judgment Gets Expensive","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fagentic-coding-engineer-skills","news\u002Finsights\u002Fagentic-coding-engineer-skills",{"title":82,"path":83,"stem":84},"The Rise of AI Agents in Cyberattacks: Latest Research and Threats","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fai-agent-cyber-threats","news\u002Finsights\u002Fai-agent-cyber-threats",{"title":86,"path":87,"stem":88},"Winning the Bid Is Not the Same as Knowing the Price","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fai-agent-economics","news\u002Finsights\u002Fai-agent-economics",{"title":90,"path":91,"stem":92},"The Smart Enterprise AI Stack: Why Teams of AI Agents Beat Solo Models Consistently","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fai-architecture","news\u002Finsights\u002Fai-architecture",{"title":94,"path":95,"stem":96},"When Seeing Everything Becomes the Only Option","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fai-comprehensive-observability","news\u002Finsights\u002Fai-comprehensive-observability",{"title":98,"path":99,"stem":100},"The Data Infrastructure AI-Native Systems Can't Ignore","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fai-data-layer","news\u002Finsights\u002Fai-data-layer",{"title":102,"path":103,"stem":104},"Enterprise AI Triage Systems: Intelligent Automation for Large-Scale Operations","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fai-enterprise-triage","news\u002Finsights\u002Fai-enterprise-triage",{"title":106,"path":107,"stem":108},"When Oversight Becomes Infrastructure","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fai-governed-autonomy","news\u002Finsights\u002Fai-governed-autonomy",{"title":110,"path":111,"stem":112},"Designing for Graceful Failure in Compound AI Systems","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fai-graceful-failure","news\u002Finsights\u002Fai-graceful-failure",{"title":114,"path":115,"stem":116},"Intelligent Composability: Building AI Systems Like Orchestra, Not Soloists","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fai-intelligent-composability","news\u002Finsights\u002Fai-intelligent-composability",{"title":118,"path":119,"stem":120},"Building the Plane While Flying It — Migrating from Monolith to AI-Native Without Stopping","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fai-migration-path","news\u002Finsights\u002Fai-migration-path",{"title":122,"path":123,"stem":124},"Stability Through Continuous Adaptation","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fai-native-overview","news\u002Finsights\u002Fai-native-overview",{"title":126,"path":127,"stem":128},"Provable Stability: Mathematical Guarantees for Adaptive AI Systems","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fai-provable-stability","news\u002Finsights\u002Fai-provable-stability",{"title":130,"path":131,"stem":132},"How Temperature Tuning Makes or Breaks Reinforcement Learning","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fai-soft-actor-critic-entropy-collapse","news\u002Finsights\u002Fai-soft-actor-critic-entropy-collapse",{"title":134,"path":135,"stem":136},"Testing What Can't Be Predicted","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fai-systems-testing","news\u002Finsights\u002Fai-systems-testing",{"title":138,"path":139,"stem":140},"Delegating the Job Is Not the Same as Delegating the Rules","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fauthorization-drift-multi-agent","news\u002Finsights\u002Fauthorization-drift-multi-agent",{"title":142,"path":143,"stem":144},"Closing the Loop: How Human Corrections Can Make AI Systems Smarter Over Time","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fclosing-the-loop","news\u002Finsights\u002Fclosing-the-loop",{"title":146,"path":147,"stem":148},"A Panel Can Be Safer Than Any Member of It","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fcoalitional-alignment-panel-review","news\u002Finsights\u002Fcoalitional-alignment-panel-review",{"title":150,"path":151,"stem":152},"Multi-Path Reasoning: Collaborative and Competitive Approaches in AI","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fcollaborative-competitive-agents","news\u002Finsights\u002Fcollaborative-competitive-agents",{"title":154,"path":155,"stem":156},"Why Challenges Supercharge Smarts for Humans and AI","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fcompetition-improves-ai","news\u002Finsights\u002Fcompetition-improves-ai",{"title":158,"path":159,"stem":160},"Context is Infrastructure, Not Instructions","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fcontext-is-infrastructure","news\u002Finsights\u002Fcontext-is-infrastructure",{"title":162,"path":163,"stem":164},"Context is the New Code","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fcontext-is-new-code","news\u002Finsights\u002Fcontext-is-new-code",{"title":166,"path":167,"stem":168},"Continuous Thought Machines","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fcontinuous-thought-machines","news\u002Finsights\u002Fcontinuous-thought-machines",{"title":170,"path":171,"stem":172},"Don't Vibe, Architect","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fdont-vibe-architect","news\u002Finsights\u002Fdont-vibe-architect",{"title":174,"path":175,"stem":176},"The Edge of the Underdefined","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fedge-of-the-underdefined","news\u002Finsights\u002Fedge-of-the-underdefined",{"title":178,"path":179,"stem":180},"Experts All the Way Down","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fexperts-all-the-way","news\u002Finsights\u002Fexperts-all-the-way",{"title":182,"path":183,"stem":184},"A Multi-Tier Safety Architecture for Critical Applications","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Ffour-tier-architecture","news\u002Finsights\u002Ffour-tier-architecture",{"title":186,"path":187,"stem":188},"Green Dashboard, Unhappy Users","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fgreen-dashboard-unhappy-users","news\u002Finsights\u002Fgreen-dashboard-unhappy-users",{"title":190,"path":191,"stem":192},"Hybrid Autoregressive Residual Tokens","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fhart-model","news\u002Finsights\u002Fhart-model",{"title":194,"path":195,"stem":196},"Hierarchical Reasoning in Artificial Intelligence","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fhierarchical-approaches","news\u002Finsights\u002Fhierarchical-approaches",{"title":198,"path":199,"stem":200},"Taking Turns Instead of Splitting the Difference","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Finterleaved-distillation-rl","news\u002Finsights\u002Finterleaved-distillation-rl",{"title":202,"path":203,"stem":204},"Latent Diffusion for Language Generation: A Comprehensive Overview","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Flatent-diffusion-for-language","news\u002Finsights\u002Flatent-diffusion-for-language",{"title":206,"path":207,"stem":208},"Breaking Language Barriers: How AI Can Translate Without Examples","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Flearning-languages","news\u002Finsights\u002Flearning-languages",{"title":210,"path":211,"stem":212},"The Emergence of AI Deception: How Large Language Models Have Learned to Strategically Mislead Users","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fllm-deception","news\u002Finsights\u002Fllm-deception",{"title":214,"path":215,"stem":216},"Grading on a Shared Curve","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fllm-judge-correlated-errors","news\u002Finsights\u002Fllm-judge-correlated-errors",{"title":218,"path":219,"stem":220},"Synergizing Specialized Reasoning and General Capabilities in AI","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fllm-reasoning-advances","news\u002Finsights\u002Fllm-reasoning-advances",{"title":222,"path":223,"stem":224},"The Expensive Default","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fllm-routing-cost-quality","news\u002Finsights\u002Fllm-routing-cost-quality",{"title":226,"path":227,"stem":228},"The AI That Rewrites Itself: MIT's Breakthrough in Self-Adapting Language Models","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fllm-seal","news\u002Finsights\u002Fllm-seal",{"title":230,"path":231,"stem":232},"Forgetting on Request","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fmachine-unlearning-removal-suppression","news\u002Finsights\u002Fmachine-unlearning-removal-suppression",{"title":234,"path":235,"stem":236},"The Map and the Walk","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fmap-and-walk","news\u002Finsights\u002Fmap-and-walk",{"title":238,"path":239,"stem":240},"Metacognitive Reinforcement Learning for Self-Improving AI Systems","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fmetacognitive-reinforcement-learning","news\u002Finsights\u002Fmetacognitive-reinforcement-learning",{"title":242,"path":243,"stem":244},"Revolutionary Advancements in Mixture of Experts (MoE) Architectures","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fmixture-of-experts","news\u002Finsights\u002Fmixture-of-experts",{"title":246,"path":247,"stem":248},"One Model, Many Customers, and the Leak Nobody Tests For","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fmulti-tenant-ai-isolation","news\u002Finsights\u002Fmulti-tenant-ai-isolation",{"title":250,"path":251,"stem":252},"Balancing Neural Plasticity and Stability","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fneural-plasticity","news\u002Finsights\u002Fneural-plasticity",{"title":254,"path":255,"stem":256},"Offline RL and the Data Flywheel","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Foffline-rl-data-flywheel","news\u002Finsights\u002Foffline-rl-data-flywheel",{"title":258,"path":259,"stem":260},"Orchestration Without a Signal From the Room","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fplanner-in-the-loop","news\u002Finsights\u002Fplanner-in-the-loop",{"title":262,"path":263,"stem":264},"Second-Guessing Has a Price","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Freasoning-budget-allocation","news\u002Finsights\u002Freasoning-budget-allocation",{"title":266,"path":267,"stem":268},"Reasoning You Can Check","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Freasoning-you-can-check","news\u002Finsights\u002Freasoning-you-can-check",{"title":270,"path":271,"stem":272},"When Optimization Optimizes Itself","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Frecursive-goodhart","news\u002Finsights\u002Frecursive-goodhart",{"title":274,"path":275,"stem":276},"Reward Design as Architecture","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Freward-design-as-architecture","news\u002Finsights\u002Freward-design-as-architecture",{"title":278,"path":279,"stem":280},"When Success Has No Author: The Temporal Credit Assignment Problem","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Frl-credit-assignment-problem","news\u002Finsights\u002Frl-credit-assignment-problem",{"title":282,"path":283,"stem":284},"Beyond Entropy Collapse: When Exploration Succeeds but Learning Fails","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Frl-optimization-gaps","news\u002Finsights\u002Frl-optimization-gaps",{"title":286,"path":287,"stem":288},"The Body Was Supposed to Be the Easy Part","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Frobot-embodiment-interface","news\u002Finsights\u002Frobot-embodiment-interface",{"title":290,"path":291,"stem":292},"The Path to Practical Confidential Computing for AI Systems","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fsecure-ai-architectures","news\u002Finsights\u002Fsecure-ai-architectures",{"title":294,"path":295,"stem":296},"When an AI Edits Its Own Memory","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fself-editing-agent-memory","news\u002Finsights\u002Fself-editing-agent-memory",{"title":298,"path":299,"stem":300},"The Guard at the Front Door","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fshallow-safety-alignment-refusal","news\u002Finsights\u002Fshallow-safety-alignment-refusal",{"title":302,"path":303,"stem":304},"Guess First, Check Later","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fspeculative-execution-pattern","news\u002Finsights\u002Fspeculative-execution-pattern",{"title":306,"path":307,"stem":308},"Spiking Neural Networks for Energy-Efficient AI","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fspiking-neural-networks","news\u002Finsights\u002Fspiking-neural-networks",{"title":310,"path":311,"stem":312},"When Replay Is Not an Option: Streaming Q-Learning and SARSA Get a Second Look","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fstreaming-q-learning-revival","news\u002Finsights\u002Fstreaming-q-learning-revival",{"title":314,"path":315,"stem":316},"The Turn as the Unit of Quality","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fstructured-iteration-quality","news\u002Finsights\u002Fstructured-iteration-quality",{"title":318,"path":319,"stem":320},"AI Speech Translation: Breaking Down Language Barriers","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fsts-performance-advances","news\u002Finsights\u002Fsts-performance-advances",{"title":322,"path":323,"stem":324},"Test-Time Training Layers: The Next Evolution in Transformer Architecture","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Ftest-time-training-layers","news\u002Finsights\u002Ftest-time-training-layers",{"title":326,"path":327,"stem":328},"The Part You Meant to Keep","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fthe-part-you-meant-to-keep","news\u002Finsights\u002Fthe-part-you-meant-to-keep",{"title":330,"path":331,"stem":332},"Predicting the Next Second: Tile Coding as a Real-Time Prediction Engine","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Ftile-coding-real-time-prediction","news\u002Finsights\u002Ftile-coding-real-time-prediction",{"title":334,"path":335,"stem":336},"Breakthrough: Large Language Models Pass the Turing Test","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fturing-tests","news\u002Finsights\u002Fturing-tests",{"title":338,"path":339,"stem":340},"Algorithms Used in Autonomous Fighter Jet Flight Research","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fvenom-f16-flight-autonomy","news\u002Finsights\u002Fvenom-f16-flight-autonomy",{"title":342,"path":343,"stem":344},"Training in a World That Does Not Exist Yet","\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fworld-models-as-infrastructure","news\u002Finsights\u002Fworld-models-as-infrastructure",{"title":346,"path":347,"stem":348},"Privacy Policy","\u002Fprivacy","privacy",{"title":350,"path":351,"stem":352},"Research","\u002Fresearch","research",{"title":354,"path":355,"stem":356},"Terms of Service","\u002Fterms","terms",{"id":358,"title":78,"body":359,"date":763,"description":764,"extension":765,"image":766,"meta":767,"navigation":779,"path":79,"seo":780,"stem":80,"__hash__":781},"insights\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fagentic-coding-engineer-skills.md",{"type":360,"value":361,"toc":747},"minimark",[362,381,391,395,421,424,433,437,447,452,462,465,489,493,503,513,516,520,526,539,547,557,567,571,584,592,600,604,607,610,615],[363,364,367,368,367,374],"div",{"className":365},[366],"page-title","\n  ",[369,370,78],"h1",{"className":371,"id":373},[372],"page-title__main","when-code-gets-cheap-judgment-gets-expensive",[375,376,380],"h2",{"className":377,"id":379},[378],"page-title__sub","agentic-coding-speeds-up-the-typing-the-evidence-suggests-the-scarce-work-moves-to-specifying-checking-and-maintaining","Agentic Coding Speeds Up the Typing. The Evidence Suggests the Scarce Work Moves to Specifying, Checking and Maintaining.",[363,382,384,385],{"style":383},"width: 100%; padding: 2%;","\n    ",[386,387],"img",{"src":388,"alt":389,"style":390},"https:\u002F\u002Fimages.unsplash.com\u002Fphoto-1515879218367-8466d910aaa4?w=1200&auto=format&fit=crop","Close view of Python source code on a dark editor screen","width: 100%; height: auto;",[392,393,394],"p",{},"Ask a room of engineers how much faster AI coding tools make them and the answers tend to come back as multipliers, sometimes two, sometimes ten for the right kind of task. From the keyboard those numbers feel accurate. A function that used to take twenty minutes of typing now appears in a few seconds, and that change is hard to miss.",[392,396,397,398,406,407,413,414,420],{},"The controlled evidence is more uneven. In an early lab experiment, developers given an AI pair programmer, a tool that suggests code as the person types, finished a small web server task about 56 percent faster than a control group ",[399,400,401],"sup",{},[402,403,405],"a",{"href":404},"#source-1","[1]",". Field trials at three large companies, with several thousand developers doing their ordinary work, found a smaller and noisier gain in completed tasks, and the less experienced developers benefited most ",[399,408,409],{},[402,410,412],{"href":411},"#source-2","[2]",". A randomized trial with experienced open-source maintainers, working in large repositories they knew well, pointed the other way. With AI tools allowed, their tasks took about 19 percent longer, even though the same developers believed afterwards that the tools had sped them up ",[399,415,416],{},[402,417,419],{"href":418},"#source-3","[3]",".",[392,422,423],{},"One way to reconcile those results is to stop treating productivity as a single dial. Writing code is one station in a longer line. Before it comes deciding what to build and describing it precisely enough for someone, or something, else to build it. After it comes checking what came back and living with it for years. AI tools have made the writing station far cheaper. So far they have done much less for the others. When one station on an assembly line speeds up, the line does not run ten times faster. The queue moves to the next slowest station. For software, the evidence suggests that station is human judgment, and the skills gaining value are the ones that work there.",[392,425,426,427,429,430,432],{},"That framing picks up where The Meta-Engineer, an earlier Thinkata series, left off. ",[402,428,170],{"href":171}," looked at how professional developers plan, delegate and validate agent work, and ",[402,431,174],{"href":175}," asked which parts of engineering stay human as agents improve. This piece comes at the same shift from the measurement side, asking what the productivity numbers actually capture and what they leave out.",[375,434,436],{"id":435},"from-autocomplete-to-delegation","From Autocomplete to Delegation",[392,438,439,440,446],{},"The tools have changed shape, and that matters for where the queue forms. Early assistants completed a line or a block. Agentic coding tools, systems that can read a repository, edit several files, run the tests and retry on failure without a person typing each step, take a task description and return a finished change. One measurement effort tracks the length of task an AI system can complete on its own, expressed as how long the same task takes a skilled human. That horizon has been doubling roughly every seven months since 2019 ",[399,441,442],{},[402,443,445],{"href":444},"#source-4","[4]",". As it grows, more of the human's day shifts from typing alongside the tool to handing it a job and judging the result.",[392,448,449,451],{},[402,450,170],{"href":171}," described two ways developers work with agents, acceleration on familiar tasks where the goal is speed, and exploration of unfamiliar territory where the goal is learning. That split matters for the productivity numbers. Large speedups live in acceleration, because the person already holds the answer and only needs it typed. Exploration depends on being able to tell which of several plausible options is actually right, and that check runs at human speed.",[392,453,454,455,461],{},"One study logged what programmers spent their time on during assisted sessions. Verifying suggestions took more of the session than writing new functionality did, and checking plus editing the tool's output together took up a large share of the total ",[399,456,457],{},[402,458,460],{"href":459},"#source-5","[5]",". From a systems perspective that is close to what a pipeline model predicts. Generation got cheap, but every generated line still passes through a reviewer, and the reviewer still runs at human speed.",[392,463,464],{},"This also offers one reading of the open-source slowdown. A small, self-contained lab task is nearly pure acceleration, because the spec is clear and the context fits in a paragraph. A mature repository is full of unwritten conventions, old decisions and edge cases that live in the maintainers' heads. In that setting the time saved on typing can go straight back into explaining context to the tool and checking whether it was respected.",[363,466,384,468,384,472,384,478],{"style":467},"width: 100%; margin: 20px 0;",[386,469],{"src":470,"alt":471,"style":390},"https:\u002F\u002Fimages.unsplash.com\u002Fphoto-1581092160562-40aa08e78837?w=1200&auto=format&fit=crop","Overhead view of an engineer marking up technical drawings with a pen",[473,474,477],"h3",{"style":475,"id":476},"margin: 1rem 0 0.5rem 0;","the-pen-does-more-of-the-work","The Pen Does More of the Work",[392,479,481,482,488],{"style":480},"margin: 0;","A stack of technical drawings becomes something buildable only after someone has gone over each sheet, circling the dimension that does not match and the hole that will not line up. Agent-written pull requests seem to follow the same path. Across several hundred pull requests produced with an agentic coding tool in open-source projects, most were eventually merged, yet close to half of the merged ones needed human revisions first, most often for bugs, documentation and project-specific conventions ",[399,483,484],{},[402,485,487],{"href":486},"#source-6","[6]",". The agent drafted the change. Someone who knew the project still had to go over it.",[375,490,492],{"id":491},"the-bill-arrives-later","The Bill Arrives Later",[392,494,495,496,502],{},"What happens when review does not keep pace? A difference-in-differences study, a method that compares projects adopting a tool with similar projects that did not, before and after adoption, followed open-source projects that started using an AI-first code editor ",[399,497,498],{},[402,499,501],{"href":500},"#source-7","[7]",". Development velocity jumped after adoption and then faded. Static analysis warnings, automated flags for likely bugs and risky patterns, rose and stayed high, and so did measures of code complexity. The authors' modeling points to that accumulated complexity as a major factor in the later slowdown. In effect, the early speed was borrowed against future maintenance.",[392,504,505,506,512],{},"Security shows a similar pattern with a human twist. In a controlled experiment, participants with an AI assistant wrote less secure code than those without one, yet were more likely to believe their code was secure ",[399,507,508],{},[402,509,511],{"href":510},"#source-8","[8]",". Participants who trusted the assistant less, and who rephrased and adjusted their prompts more actively, introduced fewer vulnerabilities. What separated them looks like calibrated distrust, a sense of when output that looks finished has not really been checked.",[392,514,515],{},"Both findings sit on the same gap the open-source trial exposed, the distance between how productive AI-assisted work feels and what it delivers once someone has to own it. That gap is plausibly where engineering skill now earns most of its value.",[375,517,519],{"id":518},"skills-gaining-weight","Skills Gaining Weight",[392,521,522,523,525],{},"If the scarce work has moved toward specification and verification, the skills that matter are likely to move with it. None of them is new, and ",[402,524,170],{"href":171}," found experienced developers already working this way, planning before they delegate and validating everything that comes back. What seems to be changing is their share of the job, and how early in a career they are needed.",[363,527,384,528,384,532,384,536],{"style":467},[386,529],{"src":530,"alt":531,"style":390},"https:\u002F\u002Fimages.unsplash.com\u002Fphoto-1434030216411-0b793f4b4173?w=1200&auto=format&fit=crop","A hand writing notes with a pen on paper beside a coffee cup",[473,533,535],{"style":475,"id":534},"a-task-written-down-is-a-task-that-can-be-checked","A Task Written Down Is a Task That Can Be Checked",[392,537,538],{"style":480},"A pen on a blank page forces choices that a quick request in conversation can skip. Specification, describing a change precisely enough that someone without the surrounding context could carry it out, has long been a senior engineering skill. With agents it becomes an everyday one. The quality of the task description puts a ceiling on the quality of the change, and a spec that names its acceptance tests also hands the reviewer something concrete to check against.",[392,540,541,542,546],{},"Decomposition sits right beside it. Agents do well on tasks with clear boundaries, and the length of task they can handle, while growing, is still finite ",[399,543,544],{},[402,545,445],{"href":444},". Splitting a feature into pieces that each fit inside that horizon, and that can each be verified on their own, is a design skill closer to architecture than to typing.",[392,548,549,550,556],{},"A less obvious skill is shaping the environment the agent works in. Work on SWE-agent, a research system that lets a language model fix real bugs in real repositories, found that the design of the agent-computer interface, the set of commands the agent uses to search, view and edit files and to run tests, had a large effect on how often it succeeded ",[399,551,552],{},[402,553,555],{"href":554},"#source-9","[9]",". The same underlying model did markedly better with tools built around its limitations. For a working team, the equivalent is the test suite, the lint rules, the written project instructions and the fast feedback loops that let an agent catch its own mistakes before a person has to. Engineers who build that scaffolding raise the ceiling on every task anyone delegates afterwards.",[392,558,559,560,562,563,420],{},"Then there is review, which now covers a larger share of the work and asks something slightly different of the reviewer. An agent does not get tired or cut corners on purpose, but it also has no memory of which shortcuts the team agreed to avoid. The reviewer has to hold the architecture in mind and ask whether a change that passes its tests also fits the system. ",[402,561,174],{"href":175}," argued that this kind of taste lives in the fit between code and human intentions, which is part of why it resists automation. The complexity findings above suggest it is also easy to lose under delivery pressure ",[399,564,565],{},[402,566,501],{"href":500},[375,568,570],{"id":569},"where-judgment-comes-from","Where Judgment Comes From",[392,572,573,574,576,577,583],{},"A harder question follows about how that judgment gets built in the first place. ",[402,575,174],{"href":175}," raised the practitioner worry about junior engineers shipping code nobody on the team understands, and asked how judgment develops if the routine work that used to train it goes away. Controlled evidence on that question has started to appear. A randomized experiment on developers learning an unfamiliar programming library found that those working with AI assistance scored worse afterwards on conceptual understanding, code reading and debugging, without a significant gain in speed on average ",[399,578,579],{},[402,580,582],{"href":581},"#source-10","[10]",". Participants who handed the coding over entirely saw some speedup but learned the least.",[392,585,586,587,591],{},"The same study found that the cost was not spread evenly. Several interaction patterns preserved learning, including asking only conceptual questions, and generating code and then asking the assistant to explain it ",[399,588,589],{},[402,590,582],{"href":581},". What those patterns share is that the person kept doing the thinking and used the tool to check or extend it.",[392,593,594,595,599],{},"Set that beside the field trials, where less experienced developers gained the most output from AI tools ",[399,596,597],{},[402,598,412],{"href":411},", and a tension appears. The engineers with the most to gain in short-term output may also be the ones whose long-term skill formation is most exposed. A team pushing for multiplied output from its newest engineers could find, a few years on, that it has fewer people able to do the review and architecture work the agents depend on.",[375,601,603],{"id":602},"looking-ahead","Looking Ahead",[392,605,606],{},"Across these studies the multiplier looks real at the station where code is typed, and much smaller, sometimes negative, once the work includes understanding a large system, verifying the result and maintaining it afterwards. That suggests a practical way to read any 10x claim, which is to ask which station was measured and over what time span.",[392,608,609],{},"For individual engineers, the evidence points toward skills that resemble what strong senior engineers already practice, clear written specs, careful decomposition, investment in tests and tooling, skeptical review and a feel for architecture, now exercised at higher volume and much earlier in a career. For teams, it suggests measuring outcomes over a longer horizon than a sprint, since the velocity gains and the complexity costs arrive on different schedules.",[392,611,612,614],{},[402,613,174],{"href":175}," closed on the idea that engineers move to wherever meaning is still underdefined. The productivity evidence adds a practical footnote. Working at that edge seems to depend on judgment built through close contact with code, and the early results on learning-preserving interaction patterns hint that the same tools can either support that contact or erode it, depending on how they are used. Whether that holds outside a single experiment, and across a whole career, is a question the field has only begun to study.",[363,616,367,620,367,623],{"className":617},[618,619],"references","mt-8",[375,621,622],{"id":618},"References",[624,625,384,631,384,649,384,661,384,672,384,682,384,693,384,703,384,713,384,725,384,736,367],"ol",{"className":626},[627,628,629,630],"list-decimal","list-inside","space-y-2","mt-4",[632,633,635,636,640,641],"li",{"id":634},"source-1","S. Peng et al., \"The Impact of AI on Developer Productivity: Evidence from GitHub Copilot,\" ",[637,638,639],"em",{},"arXiv",", 2023, ",[402,642,648],{"href":643,"target":644,"className":645},"https:\u002F\u002Farxiv.org\u002Fabs\u002F2302.06590","_blank",[646,647],"text-blue-600","underline","[Online]",[632,650,652,653,656,657],{"id":651},"source-2","Z. Cui et al., \"The Effects of Generative AI on High-Skilled Work: Evidence from Three Field Experiments with Software Developers,\" ",[637,654,655],{},"Management Science",", Articles in Advance. DOI: ",[402,658,648],{"href":659,"target":644,"className":660},"https:\u002F\u002Fdoi.org\u002F10.1287\u002Fmnsc.2025.00535",[646,647],[632,662,664,665,667,668],{"id":663},"source-3","J. Becker et al., \"Measuring the Impact of Early-2025 AI on Experienced Open-Source Developer Productivity,\" ",[637,666,639],{},", 2025, ",[402,669,648],{"href":670,"target":644,"className":671},"https:\u002F\u002Farxiv.org\u002Fabs\u002F2507.09089",[646,647],[632,673,675,676,667,678],{"id":674},"source-4","T. Kwa et al., \"Measuring AI Ability to Complete Long Software Tasks,\" ",[637,677,639],{},[402,679,648],{"href":680,"target":644,"className":681},"https:\u002F\u002Farxiv.org\u002Fabs\u002F2503.14499",[646,647],[632,683,685,686,688,689],{"id":684},"source-5","H. Mozannar et al., \"Reading Between the Lines: Modeling User Behavior and Costs in AI-Assisted Programming,\" ",[637,687,639],{},", 2022, ",[402,690,648],{"href":691,"target":644,"className":692},"https:\u002F\u002Farxiv.org\u002Fabs\u002F2210.14306",[646,647],[632,694,696,697,667,699],{"id":695},"source-6","M. Watanabe et al., \"On the Use of Agentic Coding: An Empirical Study of Pull Requests on GitHub,\" ",[637,698,639],{},[402,700,648],{"href":701,"target":644,"className":702},"https:\u002F\u002Farxiv.org\u002Fabs\u002F2509.14745",[646,647],[632,704,706,707,667,709],{"id":705},"source-7","H. He et al., \"Speed at the Cost of Quality: How Cursor AI Increases Short-Term Velocity and Long-Term Complexity in Open-Source Projects,\" ",[637,708,639],{},[402,710,648],{"href":711,"target":644,"className":712},"https:\u002F\u002Farxiv.org\u002Fabs\u002F2511.04427",[646,647],[632,714,716,717,720,721],{"id":715},"source-8","N. Perry et al., \"Do Users Write More Insecure Code with AI Assistants?,\" in ",[637,718,719],{},"Proc. ACM SIGSAC Conference on Computer and Communications Security (CCS'23)",", 2023, pp. 2785–2799. arXiv: ",[402,722,648],{"href":723,"target":644,"className":724},"https:\u002F\u002Farxiv.org\u002Fabs\u002F2211.03622",[646,647],[632,726,728,729,731,732],{"id":727},"source-9","J. Yang et al., \"SWE-agent: Agent-Computer Interfaces Enable Automated Software Engineering,\" ",[637,730,639],{},", 2024, ",[402,733,648],{"href":734,"target":644,"className":735},"https:\u002F\u002Farxiv.org\u002Fabs\u002F2405.15793",[646,647],[632,737,739,740,742,743],{"id":738},"source-10","J. H. Shen and A. Tamkin, \"How AI Impacts Skill Formation,\" ",[637,741,639],{},", 2026, ",[402,744,648],{"href":745,"target":644,"className":746},"https:\u002F\u002Farxiv.org\u002Fabs\u002F2601.20245",[646,647],{"title":748,"searchDepth":749,"depth":749,"links":750},"",2,[751,752,756,757,760,761,762],{"id":379,"depth":749,"text":380},{"id":435,"depth":749,"text":436,"children":753},[754],{"id":476,"depth":755,"text":477},3,{"id":491,"depth":749,"text":492},{"id":518,"depth":749,"text":519,"children":758},[759],{"id":534,"depth":755,"text":535},{"id":569,"depth":749,"text":570},{"id":602,"depth":749,"text":603},{"id":618,"depth":749,"text":622},"2026-10-26","Agentic coding tools have made writing code far cheaper. The controlled evidence suggests the bottleneck moves rather than disappears, toward specifying, checking and maintaining, and the engineering skills worth building move with it.","md",{"src":388},{"authors":768,"badge":774,"source":776},[769],{"avatar":770,"name":772,"to":773},{"src":771},"\u002Fimg\u002Fmark_avatar.png","Mark Williams","#",{"label":775},"Agentic Coding",{"name":777,"url":778},"Thinkata Research","https:\u002F\u002Fthinkata.com",true,{"title":78,"description":764},"L3CVCVdkwDh7-6NBw3H3d1n_1Qw-G2IrTMxzPRjwBu0",[783,1231],{"id":784,"title":326,"body":785,"date":1218,"description":1219,"extension":765,"image":1220,"meta":1222,"navigation":779,"path":327,"seo":1229,"stem":328,"__hash__":1230,"_path":327},"insights\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fthe-part-you-meant-to-keep.md",{"type":360,"value":786,"toc":1208},[787,799,802,810,814,820,823,831,835,843,851,855,863,871,874,970,977,983,987,995,1003,1011,1017,1021,1024,1096,1099,1103,1109,1117,1120],[363,788,367,790,367,794],{"className":789},[366],[369,791,326],{"className":792,"id":793},[372],"the-part-you-meant-to-keep",[375,795,798],{"className":796,"id":797},[378],"is-there-a-point-where-ai-help-turns-into-harm-and-could-a-scale-find-it","Is There a Point Where AI Help Turns Into Harm, and Could a Scale Find It?",[392,800,801],{},"Few people ask whether a letter went through spell-check. The small bottle of correction fluid that once sat beside the typewriter went away with the carbon paper, and the red underline that replaced it stopped being a topic of conversation long ago. A cover letter written with a chatbot still draws suspicion, and detectors and watermarks exist to answer whether a model was involved. As models settle into ordinary revision, a different question may matter more. Did the help cost anything, and at what point?",[392,803,804,805,809],{},"Psychologists call this cognitive offloading, using a physical action to make a task less demanding on the mind, like setting a phone reminder instead of memorizing a date ",[399,806,807],{},[402,808,405],{"href":404},". Usually that is a fair trade. So where does a convenience start to become a loss? Is there a line, and could anyone measure it?",[375,811,813],{"id":812},"the-cost-arrives-later","The Cost Arrives Later",[363,815,384,816],{"style":383},[386,817],{"src":818,"alt":819,"style":390},"https:\u002F\u002Fimages.unsplash.com\u002Fphoto-1793393444608-3886cf95b354?w=1200&auto=format&fit=crop","A lifter on a bench press with a spotter standing behind the bar",[392,821,822],{},"The spotter's hands rest at the hips until the bar stalls. A nudge on the last repetition finishes the set, and the lifter's chest still did the work. Lifting from the first repetition would move the same weight along the same path, and nothing about the bar would show the difference. AI help has a similar measurement problem. The output can look fine either way, and any cost tends to appear once the hands come away.",[392,824,825,826,830],{},"How quickly can that happen? Across three randomized experiments, people practiced fractions or reading comprehension in sessions of about a quarter of an hour, some with a chatbot beside them, then took a short test alone. The chatbot helped during practice. On the test, those in the first experiment who had used it solved 57 percent of problems, compared with 74 percent for those who had not, and they gave up more often ",[399,827,828],{},[402,829,412],{"href":411},". The gap was smaller in a replication, and testing came right after practice, so the authors leave open whether the effect builds or fades with daily use.",[375,832,834],{"id":833},"counting-requests-misses-it","Counting Requests Misses It",[392,836,837,838,842],{},"The obvious dial is quantity. Could some number of requests per task, or hours per week, mark the point of trouble? One small experiment points elsewhere. In it, 124 adults worked through logic puzzles, most with a simulated assistant whose price per request varied. Once starting ability was accounted for, request counts said almost nothing about skill gained. What tracked it was solo share, the fraction of time a person worked alone on a problem before asking ",[399,839,840],{},[402,841,419],{"href":418},". Scores while assisted also overstated how people later did on their own, which suggests that a session going well is a poor guide.",[392,844,845,846,850],{},"A larger experiment on fraction practice gives the nearest thing to a dose curve. Each extra 10 percentage points of problems on which someone requested the full answer came with 32 percent lower odds of getting a later test question right ",[399,847,848],{},[402,849,445],{"href":444},". That analysis is correlational, and it assumes a smooth trend, so a sharper break could be hiding inside it. Access alone produced no detectable harm in that study, perhaps because the assistant gave full answers only when explicitly asked. No study found in this research set out to look for a break point. For now a ramp seems at least as plausible as a cliff, which is inconvenient for anyone hoping to draw one line.",[375,852,854],{"id":853},"five-rungs-drawn-in-pencil","Five Rungs, Drawn in Pencil",[392,856,857,858,862],{},"If quantity is a weak guide, depth looks stronger. In the replication of those short experiments, people who said they mostly asked for hints scored about the same as people with no chatbot, while those who mostly asked for answers fell behind ",[399,859,860],{},[402,861,412],{"href":411},". Those groups chose their own habits, so the comparison only suggests a cause.",[392,864,865,866,870],{},"One recent writing study offers a vocabulary for depth. It separates four layers, surface (grammar and local wording), structural (outlines and organization), idea (claims and examples) and reasoning (evidence interpretation and argumentative logic), with coders rating each from 1, where the writer did the work, to 5, where the tool did it and little changed. Over an eight-week course, heavier offloading at every layer went with weaker thinking on later no-AI tasks, and the cost of open access ran most faintly through the surface layer and most strongly through reasoning ",[399,867,868],{},[402,869,460],{"href":459},". Open-access writers also sent nearly twice as many prompts per task, yet far fewer of their revisions were writer-led, so more turns may not mean more involvement. Six classes without random assignment can only suggest so much, and the author says the framework still needs independent validation.",[392,872,873],{},"Adding memory at the bottom gives a rough ladder. It was assembled for this article, and no validation stands behind it.",[875,876,877,896],"table",{},[878,879,880],"thead",{},[881,882,883,887,890,893],"tr",{},[884,885,886],"th",{},"Rung",[884,888,889],{},"What moves to the tool",[884,891,892],{},"Usually helps when",[884,894,895],{},"May start to cost when",[897,898,899,914,928,942,956],"tbody",{},[881,900,901,905,908,911],{},[902,903,904],"td",{},"1. Storing",[902,906,907],{},"Dates, lists, references",[902,909,910],{},"The facts can be looked up again",[902,912,913],{},"Recall is the skill being built",[881,915,916,919,922,925],{},[902,917,918],{},"2. Polishing",[902,920,921],{},"Spelling, grammar, local wording",[902,923,924],{},"The meaning is already settled",[902,926,927],{},"Checking stops, or edits drift into meaning",[881,929,930,933,936,939],{},[902,931,932],{},"3. Arranging",[902,934,935],{},"Outline and order",[902,937,938],{},"The person knows the material",[902,940,941],{},"The person is still learning how the pieces fit",[881,943,944,947,950,953],{},[902,945,946],{},"4. Supplying",[902,948,949],{},"Claims, examples, solutions",[902,951,952],{},"The task is routine",[902,954,955],{},"Working it out was the point",[881,957,958,961,964,967],{},[902,959,960],{},"5. Deciding",[902,962,963],{},"Interpretation and judgment",[902,965,966],{},"Stakes are low and the call is easy to check",[902,968,969],{},"The person will answer for the conclusion later",[392,971,972,973,420],{},"Even the second rung has a price. In a 2005 experiment, people with stronger verbal skills left nearly twice as many unflagged errors behind when a spelling and grammar checker was switched on ",[399,974,975],{},[402,976,487],{"href":486},[392,978,979,980,982],{},"Read across the rows and the threshold stops being a place on the ladder. One working definition might be that help turns to harm at the rung where the tool starts doing something the person wanted, or needed, to still be able to do alone. A status email can sit at rung five with little lost. A junior engineer at rung four on debugging may be giving away what the job was supposed to build, the worry behind ",[402,981,78],{"href":79},". Same ladder, opposite verdicts, so a useful scale would need to ask about intent as well as behavior.",[375,984,986],{"id":985},"the-closest-thing-to-a-number","The Closest Thing to a Number",[392,988,989,990,994],{},"Could the rungs be measured automatically? The most direct attempt found here is the Offloading Score. It reads screen recordings and keystrokes, has a language model rebuild how an average person would finish each AI-assisted step without the tool, and reports the fraction of steps saved, between 0 and 1. Among 40 freelance developers, a one-hour limit produced more offloading than a four-hour limit, 0.45 against 0.31, while self-reported mental load barely moved ",[399,991,992],{},[402,993,501],{"href":500},". People may not feel the shift as it happens.",[392,996,997,998,1002],{},"The authors also sketch an actual line, an overreliance threshold of 0.33 tied to how well developers could recall their own system. They call it illustrative and say real thresholds should be set empirically. The link to recall was weak overall and stronger only after setting aside about 30 percent of users who combined moderate to high reliance with high recall, apparently using the tool to learn ",[399,999,1000],{},[402,1001,501],{"href":500},". Those users could cross that line with no visible harm, and they may be the most interesting people in the study.",[392,1004,1005,1006,1010],{},"Questionnaires take the other route. A free self-check called PAUSE sorts readings into minimal, mild, moderate and strong bands, and its author is candid that the cut points were chosen for legibility, with no reliability or validity evidence behind them ",[399,1007,1008],{},[402,1009,511],{"href":510},". Levels are easy to print. Knowing what they mean is the hard part.",[392,1012,1013,1014,1016],{},"From a machine learning standpoint, this resembles choosing an operating point on a classifier. A score can come from logs, but the cut depends on what each kind of mistake costs, and those costs differ between an expense note and a thesis. The ground truth, what someone can do later with the tool gone, is slow and expensive to collect, and several studies above tested within minutes of practice. Then comes the feedback loop. Once anyone is judged on the number, prompts will likely get padded, the pattern ",[402,1015,270],{"href":271}," traced in systems that learn to satisfy their own metrics.",[375,1018,1020],{"id":1019},"right-use-wrong-use","Right Use, Wrong Use",[392,1022,1023],{},"Until a validated scale exists, the ladder can still sort everyday choices. Right use leaves a person able to do what they wanted to keep. Wrong use gives that ability away, often with little sign at the time. The labels depend on that goal, so the same request can land in either column. These pairings follow from the evidence above, and no study has tested them as a set.",[875,1025,1026,1039],{},[878,1027,1028],{},[881,1029,1030,1033,1036],{},[884,1031,1032],{},"Task",[884,1034,1035],{},"Right use",[884,1037,1038],{},"Wrong use",[897,1040,1041,1052,1063,1074,1085],{},[881,1042,1043,1046,1049],{},[902,1044,1045],{},"Grammar and wording",[902,1047,1048],{},"Polishing a draft with settled meaning, then checking the edits",[902,1050,1051],{},"Accepting every change unread, even when the meaning shifts",[881,1053,1054,1057,1060],{},[902,1055,1056],{},"Learning something new",[902,1058,1059],{},"Trying first, then asking for a hint",[902,1061,1062],{},"Asking for the full answer before trying",[881,1064,1065,1068,1071],{},[902,1066,1067],{},"Organizing work",[902,1069,1070],{},"Outlining familiar material",[902,1072,1073],{},"Letting the tool arrange material still being learned",[881,1075,1076,1079,1082],{},[902,1077,1078],{},"Ideas and arguments",[902,1080,1081],{},"Getting help on routine work that can be checked",[902,1083,1084],{},"Submitting an argument the writer could not explain",[881,1086,1087,1090,1093],{},[902,1088,1089],{},"Decisions",[902,1091,1092],{},"Handing off low-stakes calls that are easy to check",[902,1094,1095],{},"Handing off a conclusion the person must answer for later",[392,1097,1098],{},"A rough test fits in one question. After the session, could the person explain, defend or reproduce the parts of the work they meant to keep? A yes suggests the tool supported them. A no may be fine for a status email, as long as the trade was made on purpose.",[375,1100,1102],{"id":1101},"a-bubble-between-two-lines","A Bubble Between Two Lines",[363,1104,384,1105],{"style":383},[386,1106],{"src":1107,"alt":1108,"style":390},"https:\u002F\u002Fimages.unsplash.com\u002Fphoto-1786341594766-22826f989d0b?w=1200&auto=format&fit=crop","A yellow spirit level vial with its bubble between two black lines",[392,1110,1111,1112,1116],{},"A bubble between two lines straightens nothing. It tells the person holding the level where things stand, and the rest is up to them. That may be the more realistic job for a scale, and there is some early support for it. In the larger fraction experiment, some participants read a short note between problems describing what they had just done and what it meant for the practice they got, with no grades, points or instructions. Their odds of requesting a full answer fell by about half and they did better on the unaided test, while a points reward for effort changed neither ",[399,1113,1114],{},[402,1115,445],{"href":444},". The margins of error were wide, and it was one brief session with an immediate test, so durability remains unknown. It also hints at something awkward for anyone building a scale. The note seems to have worked without a score.",[392,1118,1119],{},"Spell-check seems to have stopped being a question once people had decided, mostly without discussing it, what they no longer needed to do themselves. That decision has not been made for reasoning, and it may not get made the same way for everyone. A scale might never find one point where help becomes harm. Could it still show a person where they stood on a given afternoon, close enough to change what they hand over next time?",[363,1121,367,1123,367,1125],{"className":1122},[618,619],[375,1124,622],{"id":618},[624,1126,384,1128,384,1139,384,1148,384,1159,384,1168,384,1179,384,1190,384,1199,367],{"className":1127},[627,628,629,630],[632,1129,1130,1131,1134,1135],{"id":634},"E. F. Risko and S. J. Gilbert, \"Cognitive Offloading,\" ",[637,1132,1133],{},"Trends in Cognitive Sciences",", vol. 20, no. 9, pp. 676–688, 2016. DOI: ",[402,1136,648],{"href":1137,"target":644,"className":1138},"https:\u002F\u002Fdoi.org\u002F10.1016\u002Fj.tics.2016.07.002",[646,647],[632,1140,1141,1142,742,1144],{"id":651},"G. Liu et al., \"AI Assistance Reduces Persistence and Hurts Independent Performance,\" ",[637,1143,639],{},[402,1145,648],{"href":1146,"target":644,"className":1147},"https:\u002F\u002Farxiv.org\u002Fabs\u002F2604.04721",[646,647],[632,1149,1150,1151,1154,1155],{"id":663},"S. Wu et al., \"How AI Assistance Affects Human Skill Development: A Study of Learning with Logic Puzzles,\" in ",[637,1152,1153],{},"Proc. ACM Conference on Human-AI Complementarity and Alignment (HCOMP 2026)",", 2026. DOI: ",[402,1156,648],{"href":1157,"target":644,"className":1158},"https:\u002F\u002Fdoi.org\u002F10.1145\u002F3834580.3838741",[646,647],[632,1160,1161,1162,742,1164],{"id":674},"S. Maier et al., \"Designing Against Deskilling: Metacognitive Feedback Reduces Cognitive Offloading to LLM Assistants,\" ",[637,1163,639],{},[402,1165,648],{"href":1166,"target":644,"className":1167},"https:\u002F\u002Farxiv.org\u002Fabs\u002F2609.20143",[646,647],[632,1169,1170,1171,1174,1175],{"id":684},"X. Chen, \"Layer-sensitive cognitive offloading in generative AI-assisted writing: supported performance and independent no-AI outcomes,\" ",[637,1172,1173],{},"Frontiers in Psychology",", vol. 17, art. 1906199, 2026. DOI: ",[402,1176,648],{"href":1177,"target":644,"className":1178},"https:\u002F\u002Fdoi.org\u002F10.3389\u002Ffpsyg.2026.1906199",[646,647],[632,1180,1181,1182,1185,1186],{"id":695},"D. F. Galletta et al., \"Does Spell-Checking Software Need a Warning Label?,\" ",[637,1183,1184],{},"Communications of the ACM",", vol. 48, no. 7, pp. 82–86, 2005. DOI: ",[402,1187,648],{"href":1188,"target":644,"className":1189},"https:\u002F\u002Fdoi.org\u002F10.1145\u002F1070838.1070841",[646,647],[632,1191,1192,1193,742,1195],{"id":705},"V. Padmakumar et al., \"Offloading Score: Measuring AI Reliance Through Counterfactual Workflows,\" ",[637,1194,639],{},[402,1196,648],{"href":1197,"target":644,"className":1198},"https:\u002F\u002Farxiv.org\u002Fabs\u002F2605.29392",[646,647],[632,1200,1201,1202,742,1204],{"id":715},"M. U. Alam, \"PAUSE: A Privacy-Preserving Self-Reflection Tool for AI-Associated Cognitive Offloading,\" ",[637,1203,639],{},[402,1205,648],{"href":1206,"target":644,"className":1207},"https:\u002F\u002Farxiv.org\u002Fabs\u002F2609.13155",[646,647],{"title":748,"searchDepth":749,"depth":749,"links":1209},[1210,1211,1212,1213,1214,1215,1216,1217],{"id":797,"depth":749,"text":798},{"id":812,"depth":749,"text":813},{"id":833,"depth":749,"text":834},{"id":853,"depth":749,"text":854},{"id":985,"depth":749,"text":986},{"id":1019,"depth":749,"text":1020},{"id":1101,"depth":749,"text":1102},{"id":618,"depth":749,"text":622},"2026-11-02","AI help tends to look good in the moment and cost something later. The evidence so far offers no single cutoff, and the line seems to move with what a person wants to keep. Could a cognitive offloading scale find it?",{"src":1221},"https:\u002F\u002Fimages.unsplash.com\u002Fphoto-1530686350401-7de25243dd89?w=1200&auto=format&fit=crop",{"authors":1223,"badge":1226,"source":1228},[1224],{"avatar":1225,"name":772,"to":773},{"src":771},{"label":1227},"Cognitive Offloading",{"name":777,"url":778},{"title":326,"description":1219},"I2CiH4E-x_25GqPZ7G3zu0bgjJ6xoQJ8ikXT2zhnVQ4",{"id":1232,"title":234,"body":1233,"date":1657,"description":1658,"extension":765,"image":1659,"meta":1661,"navigation":779,"path":235,"seo":1668,"stem":236,"__hash__":1669,"_path":235},"insights\u002Fnews\u002Finsights\u002Fmap-and-walk.md",{"type":360,"value":1234,"toc":1646},[1235,1247,1253,1256,1259,1263,1271,1276,1279,1282,1285,1292,1295,1364,1367,1371,1379,1386,1390,1406,1414,1422,1426,1434,1442,1445,1467,1470,1472,1482,1497,1507,1510,1513],[363,1236,367,1238,367,1242],{"className":1237},[366],[369,1239,234],{"className":1240,"id":1241},[372],"the-map-and-the-walk",[375,1243,1246],{"className":1244,"id":1245},[378],"how-language-models-and-reinforcement-learning-learn-differently-and-why-useful-systems-need-both","How Language Models and Reinforcement Learning Learn Differently, and Why Useful Systems Need Both",[363,1248,384,1249],{"style":383},[386,1250],{"src":1251,"alt":1252,"style":390},"https:\u002F\u002Fimages.unsplash.com\u002Fphoto-1715485717725-01a1b81528f5?w=1200&auto=format&fit=crop","A compass resting on a paper map",[392,1254,1255],{},"A paper map holds the accumulated knowledge of many earlier travelers, where the roads run, which towns sit along the river, roughly how far one is from the next. What it cannot say is whether the bridge washed out last week. Only walking the route reveals that, and a walker with no map at all can spend days discovering what any local could have explained in a sentence.",[392,1257,1258],{},"Modern AI rests on two learning methods that split the work in much the same way. A large language model, or LLM, is a neural network trained on an enormous archive of human writing to predict the next word, and in the process it absorbs a broad picture of how language, facts and arguments tend to fit together. Reinforcement learning, or RL, is learning by trial and error. A system tries an action, receives a score called a reward, and gradually shifts toward whatever earns more of it. The two are sometimes presented as competing visions of AI. In practice, many of the most capable systems in use today depend on both, and the reasons say a good deal about what each method can and cannot do alone.",[375,1260,1262],{"id":1261},"two-ways-to-learn","Two Ways to Learn",[392,1264,1265,1266,1270],{},"RL's roots run through the study of animal learning. In 1981, Richard Sutton and Andrew Barto described a simple adaptive element that learned to respond in anticipation of a stimulus, much as Pavlov's dogs learned to salivate at a bell before the food arrived ",[399,1267,1268],{},[402,1269,405],{"href":404},". The core idea, learning from the gap between what was expected and what actually happened, became central to modern RL. Its standard form is the temporal difference error, which compares the reward just received, plus the estimated value of the situation the system landed in, against the value it had predicted for the situation it started from.",[1272,1273],"math-katex",{":math":1274,":display-mode":1275},"\\delta_t = r_t + \\gamma V(s_{t+1}) - V(s_t)","true",[392,1277,1278],{},"When things turn out better than expected, the error is positive and the estimate moves up, and when they turn out worse it moves down. The Greek letter gamma is a discount factor that makes distant rewards count for a little less than immediate ones.",[392,1280,1281],{},"Language models learn from a different kind of surprise. During pretraining, the model reads text one token at a time, a token being a word or a piece of a word, and is penalized according to how little probability it gave to the token that actually came next.",[1272,1283],{":math":1284,":display-mode":1275},"\\mathcal{L} = -\\sum_{t} \\log p_\\theta(x_t \\mid x_{\u003Ct})",[392,1286,1287,1288,420],{},"Scaled up far enough, that single objective produced surprising breadth. GPT-3, trained only to predict text, could pick up a new task from a handful of examples written into its prompt, with no further training at all ",[399,1289,1290],{},[402,1291,412],{"href":411},[392,1293,1294],{},"Both methods, in other words, learn from prediction errors. The real differences lie in where the data comes from and what the feedback says.",[875,1296,1297,1309],{},[878,1298,1299],{},[881,1300,1301,1303,1306],{},[884,1302],{},[884,1304,1305],{},"Language model pretraining",[884,1307,1308],{},"Reinforcement learning",[897,1310,1311,1325,1338,1351],{},[881,1312,1313,1319,1322],{},[902,1314,1315],{},[1316,1317,1318],"strong",{},"Learns from",[902,1320,1321],{},"A fixed archive of human text",[902,1323,1324],{},"Its own attempts and their outcomes",[881,1326,1327,1332,1335],{},[902,1328,1329],{},[1316,1330,1331],{},"Feedback",[902,1333,1334],{},"The correct next token, at every position",[902,1336,1337],{},"A score, often only at the end",[881,1339,1340,1345,1348],{},[902,1341,1342],{},[1316,1343,1344],{},"Learns",[902,1346,1347],{},"What is likely",[902,1349,1350],{},"What works",[881,1352,1353,1358,1361],{},[902,1354,1355],{},[1316,1356,1357],{},"Struggles with",[902,1359,1360],{},"Goals the text never states",[902,1362,1363],{},"Getting started without a good guess",[392,1365,1366],{},"The table hides an important asymmetry. A language model is shown the right answer at every position of every sentence, which makes its signal dense and plentiful but confines it to the archive it was given. An RL system often learns only whether a whole attempt succeeded, a sparse signal, yet it can keep generating fresh experience for as long as it keeps acting.",[375,1368,1370],{"id":1369},"what-each-method-struggles-with-alone","What Each Method Struggles With Alone",[392,1372,1373,1374,1378],{},"Prediction by itself does not produce a helpful assistant. The archive includes careless answers, confident mistakes and unpleasant text, and a model trained to imitate it reproduces some of each. The team behind InstructGPT put the problem plainly, observing that making language models bigger does not inherently make them better at following what a user actually wants ",[399,1375,1376],{},[402,1377,419],{"href":418},". Their remedy, reinforcement learning from human feedback, trained a separate model to predict which of two answers people preferred and then used RL to steer the language model toward answers that scored well. People preferred the outputs of the resulting model even when it was more than a hundred times smaller than the original GPT-3.",[392,1380,1381,1382,1385],{},"RL by itself has the opposite problem. A reward only teaches something once the system produces behavior worth rewarding. A system learning to write mathematical proofs from scratch could generate an enormous amount of nonsense before stumbling onto a single valid one, and until then the reward stays silent. Rewards are also hard to specify well. A system pushed hard against an imperfect score tends to find the gap between what the score measures and what its designers meant, a problem explored in an earlier Thinkata piece on ",[402,1383,1384],{"href":275},"reward design",". From a systems perspective, a pretrained model eases the first problem directly. It starts with a strong prior, a built-in sense of what plausible text, code and plans look like, so the reward has sensible candidates to choose among from the very first attempt.",[375,1387,1389],{"id":1388},"where-the-two-already-work-together","Where the Two Already Work Together",[392,1391,1392,1393,1396,1397,1400,1401,1405],{},"The InstructGPT recipe of pretraining, then a supervised stage, then RL became a widely adopted template for chat assistants, and an earlier piece on ",[402,1394,1395],{"href":143},"human correction loops"," looks at how that feedback can keep flowing after deployment. Reasoning models extend the same pattern. In 2025, a DeepSeek team reported in ",[637,1398,1399],{},"Nature"," that RL applied to a large pretrained model, rewarded only for whether its final answers to math and coding problems were correct, produced behaviors such as checking its own work and switching strategies partway through, without any human examples of how to reason ",[399,1402,1403],{},[402,1404,445],{"href":444},". The reward came from an automatic checker rather than from people, which makes it cheap to apply at scale wherever answers can be verified.",[392,1407,1408,1409,1413],{},"Robotics shows the division of labor even more plainly. Asked how to clean up a spill, a language model can describe a sensible plan, but it has no way of knowing whether a particular robot in a particular kitchen can actually reach the sponge. The SayCan system, presented at the Conference on Robot Learning, paired a language model with a library of robot skills, each with a value function, a learned estimate of how likely that skill is to succeed from where the robot currently stands ",[399,1410,1411],{},[402,1412,460],{"href":459},". The language model proposed steps that made sense for the task, the value functions favored steps that were feasible right now, and in the authors' words the robot acted as the language model's \"hands and eyes.\"",[392,1415,1416,1417,1421],{},"The help also flows in the other direction. Writing a good reward function is one of the most tedious parts of applying RL, and Eureka, presented at ICLR in 2024, handed that job to a language model ",[399,1418,1419],{},[402,1420,487],{"href":486},". The model wrote candidate rewards as code, checked how well RL training went with each one, and revised them. Across a suite of simulated robot tasks, its rewards beat ones written by human experts on most of them, and they taught a simulated robot hand to spin a pen.",[375,1423,1425],{"id":1424},"why-the-pairing-holds-up","Why the Pairing Holds Up",[392,1427,1428,1429,1433],{},"Part of the case for the pairing comes from comparing RL with the other common way of adapting a pretrained model. A study presented at ICML in 2025 compared supervised fine-tuning, which trains a model to copy example answers, against RL trained on an outcome reward ",[399,1430,1431],{},[402,1432,501],{"href":500},". RL generalized to unseen variations of a card game and a navigation task, while supervised fine-tuning tended to memorize its examples. The same study found that the supervised stage was still needed first, because it stabilized the model's output format enough for RL to make progress.",[392,1435,1436,1437,1441],{},"A 2025 preprint adds a quieter advantage ",[399,1438,1439],{},[402,1440,511],{"href":510},". When a model learns a new task, RL appears to disturb its existing knowledge less than supervised fine-tuning does. Among the many ways to solve the new task, on-policy RL, which learns from the model's own outputs, tends to settle on the one that changes the model least. For teams that care about keeping a pretrained model's general abilities intact while teaching it something specific, that is a practical reason to reach for RL at the final step.",[392,1443,1444],{},"The pairing has limits, and the clearest ones come from asking how far the walk can stray from the map.",[363,1446,384,1447,384,1451,384,1455],{"style":467},[386,1448],{"src":1449,"alt":1450,"style":390},"https:\u002F\u002Fimages.unsplash.com\u002Fphoto-1634471887351-8bed1dbf37b3?w=1200&auto=format&fit=crop","Aerial view of a hedge maze in a field",[473,1452,1454],{"style":475,"id":1453},"counting-the-corridors","Counting the Corridors",[392,1456,1457,1458,1462,1463,420],{"style":480},"From above, every route through a maze is visible at once, including the few corridors that reach the center. A NeurIPS 2025 study looked at reasoning models from roughly that vantage point, giving each model many attempts per problem and counting a problem as solved if any attempt succeeded ",[399,1459,1460],{},[402,1461,555],{"href":554},". With one attempt, the RL-trained models clearly beat the base models they came from. With many attempts, the base models solved more. The authors concluded that the observed reasoning abilities \"originate from and are bounded by the base model,\" suggesting RL mostly taught the model to take a corridor it already knew more reliably. A 2026 preprint offers a partial counterpoint, finding that some problems the base model never solved did become solvable during RL training, and that focusing training on those problems pushed results past the base model ",[399,1464,1465],{},[402,1466,582],{"href":581},[392,1468,1469],{},"Taken together, the evidence suggests that RL is most useful as a way to select and sharpen what pretraining already makes possible, with a smaller and still debated capacity to reach beyond it. Anyone who has built a search system will recognize the shape. A retrieval stage gathers candidates and a ranking stage picks among them. A good ranker cannot surface a document the retriever never found, and a large candidate set is wasted without a ranker that can tell good from bad. Neither stage makes the other redundant.",[375,1471,603],{"id":602},[392,1473,1474,1475,1481],{},"The balance between the two may shift. A 2024 analysis presented at ICML projected that, if trends held, training datasets would reach roughly the size of the entire stock of public human-written text sometime between 2026 and 2032 ",[399,1476,1477],{},[402,1478,1480],{"href":1479},"#source-11","[11]",". Two prominent RL researchers see that as a turning point.",[1483,1484,1486,1487,1490,367,1492],"blockquote",{"style":1485},"color: #0066CC; font-size: 1em; border-left: 4px solid #0066CC; padding-left: 1em;","\n  \"In key domains such as mathematics, coding, and science, the knowledge extracted from human data is rapidly approaching a limit.\"",[1488,1489],"br",{},[1488,1491],{},[402,1493,1496],{"href":1494,"style":1495,"target":644},"http:\u002F\u002Fincompleteideas.net\u002Fpapers\u002FTheEraOfExperience.pdf","color: #0066CC; text-decoration: none;","Silver and Sutton, Welcome to the Era of Experience, 2025",[392,1498,1499,1500,1506],{},"David Silver and Richard Sutton argue that agents will increasingly generate their own training data by acting and learning from the results ",[399,1501,1502],{},[402,1503,1505],{"href":1504},"#source-12","[12]",". If that happens, it seems likely to lean on both methods at once, a pretrained model to make early attempts sensible and RL to learn from how those attempts turn out. The open question is how far experience can carry a model in domains where no automatic checker exists to say whether an answer was right.",[392,1508,1509],{},"For teams building with these methods now, a few habits follow. Single-attempt accuracy can hide a narrowing of what a model is able to do, so tracking performance across many attempts is a cheap safeguard. Rewards deserve the same scrutiny as any other specification, since a model trained against them optimizes what was written rather than what was meant. And the quality of the base model sets much of the ceiling for what fine-tuning can reach, which makes the choice of starting point one of the most consequential decisions in the pipeline.",[392,1511,1512],{},"The map and the walk seem to work best as a pair. A map with no one to walk it stays a guess about the terrain, and a walk with no map is mostly wandering. Most of the progress described here came from putting the two together.",[363,1514,367,1516,367,1518],{"className":1515},[618,619],[375,1517,622],{"id":618},[624,1519,384,1521,384,1532,384,1543,384,1553,384,1563,384,1574,384,1584,384,1595,384,1604,384,1614,384,1623,384,1635,367],{"className":1520},[627,628,629,630],[632,1522,1523,1524,1527,1528],{"id":634},"R. S. Sutton and A. G. Barto, \"Toward a Modern Theory of Adaptive Networks: Expectation and Prediction,\" ",[637,1525,1526],{},"Psychological Review",", vol. 88, no. 2, pp. 135–170, 1981. DOI: ",[402,1529,648],{"href":1530,"target":644,"className":1531},"https:\u002F\u002Fdoi.org\u002F10.1037\u002F0033-295X.88.2.135",[646,647],[632,1533,1534,1535,1538,1539],{"id":651},"T. B. Brown et al., \"Language Models are Few-Shot Learners,\" in ",[637,1536,1537],{},"Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems",", vol. 33, 2020, ",[402,1540,648],{"href":1541,"target":644,"className":1542},"https:\u002F\u002Fproceedings.neurips.cc\u002Fpaper\u002F2020\u002Fhash\u002F1457c0d6bfcb4967418bfb8ac142f64a-Abstract.html",[646,647],[632,1544,1545,1546,1548,1549],{"id":663},"L. Ouyang et al., \"Training Language Models to Follow Instructions with Human Feedback,\" in ",[637,1547,1537],{},", vol. 35, 2022, ",[402,1550,648],{"href":1551,"target":644,"className":1552},"https:\u002F\u002Fproceedings.neurips.cc\u002Fpaper_files\u002Fpaper\u002F2022\u002Fhash\u002Fb1efde53be364a73914f58805a001731-Abstract-Conference.html",[646,647],[632,1554,1555,1556,1558,1559],{"id":674},"D. Guo et al., \"DeepSeek-R1 Incentivizes Reasoning in LLMs Through Reinforcement Learning,\" ",[637,1557,1399],{},", vol. 645, pp. 633–638, 2025. DOI: ",[402,1560,648],{"href":1561,"target":644,"className":1562},"https:\u002F\u002Fdoi.org\u002F10.1038\u002Fs41586-025-09422-z",[646,647],[632,1564,1565,1566,1569,1570],{"id":684},"B. Ichter et al., \"Do As I Can, Not As I Say: Grounding Language in Robotic Affordances,\" in ",[637,1567,1568],{},"Proc. 6th Conference on Robot Learning (CoRL'22)",", PMLR vol. 205, pp. 287–318, 2023, ",[402,1571,648],{"href":1572,"target":644,"className":1573},"https:\u002F\u002Fproceedings.mlr.press\u002Fv205\u002Fichter23a.html",[646,647],[632,1575,1576,1577,731,1580],{"id":695},"Y. J. Ma et al., \"Eureka: Human-Level Reward Design via Coding Large Language Models,\" in ",[637,1578,1579],{},"Proc. International Conference on Learning Representations (ICLR'24)",[402,1581,648],{"href":1582,"target":644,"className":1583},"https:\u002F\u002Farxiv.org\u002Fabs\u002F2310.12931",[646,647],[632,1585,1586,1587,1590,1591],{"id":705},"T. Chu et al., \"SFT Memorizes, RL Generalizes: A Comparative Study of Foundation Model Post-training,\" in ",[637,1588,1589],{},"Proc. 42nd International Conference on Machine Learning (ICML'25)",", PMLR vol. 267, 2025, ",[402,1592,648],{"href":1593,"target":644,"className":1594},"https:\u002F\u002Fproceedings.mlr.press\u002Fv267\u002Fchu25c.html",[646,647],[632,1596,1597,1598,667,1600],{"id":715},"I. Shenfeld et al., \"RL's Razor: Why Online Reinforcement Learning Forgets Less,\" ",[637,1599,639],{},[402,1601,648],{"href":1602,"target":644,"className":1603},"https:\u002F\u002Farxiv.org\u002Fabs\u002F2509.04259",[646,647],[632,1605,1606,1607,1609,1610],{"id":727},"Y. Yue et al., \"Does Reinforcement Learning Really Incentivize Reasoning Capacity in LLMs Beyond the Base Model?,\" in ",[637,1608,1537],{},", vol. 38, 2025, ",[402,1611,648],{"href":1612,"target":644,"className":1613},"https:\u002F\u002Farxiv.org\u002Fabs\u002F2504.13837",[646,647],[632,1615,1616,1617,742,1619],{"id":738},"S. Yuan et al., \"Understanding Diversity Collapse in RLVR via the Lens of Overtraining,\" ",[637,1618,639],{},[402,1620,648],{"href":1621,"target":644,"className":1622},"https:\u002F\u002Farxiv.org\u002Fabs\u002F2606.15455",[646,647],[632,1624,1626,1627,1630,1631],{"id":1625},"source-11","P. Villalobos et al., \"Position: Will We Run Out of Data? Limits of LLM Scaling Based on Human-Generated Data,\" in ",[637,1628,1629],{},"Proc. 41st International Conference on Machine Learning (ICML'24)",", PMLR vol. 235, 2024, ",[402,1632,648],{"href":1633,"target":644,"className":1634},"https:\u002F\u002Fproceedings.mlr.press\u002Fv235\u002Fvillalobos24a.html",[646,647],[632,1636,1638,1639,1642,1643],{"id":1637},"source-12","D. Silver and R. S. Sutton, \"Welcome to the Era of Experience,\" preprint of a chapter in ",[637,1640,1641],{},"Designing an Intelligence",", MIT Press, 2025, ",[402,1644,648],{"href":1494,"target":644,"className":1645},[646,647],{"title":748,"searchDepth":749,"depth":749,"links":1647},[1648,1649,1650,1651,1652,1655,1656],{"id":1245,"depth":749,"text":1246},{"id":1261,"depth":749,"text":1262},{"id":1369,"depth":749,"text":1370},{"id":1388,"depth":749,"text":1389},{"id":1424,"depth":749,"text":1425,"children":1653},[1654],{"id":1453,"depth":755,"text":1454},{"id":602,"depth":749,"text":603},{"id":618,"depth":749,"text":622},"2026-10-20","Language models learn by predicting human text, while reinforcement learning learns from the outcomes of its own attempts. A look at how the two methods differ, what each struggles with on its own, and why chat assistants, reasoning models and robots increasingly rely on both.",{"src":1660},"https:\u002F\u002Fimages.unsplash.com\u002Fphoto-1715485717725-01a1b81528f5?w=1200&h=750&fit=crop&auto=format",{"authors":1662,"badge":1665,"source":1667},[1663],{"avatar":1664,"name":772,"to":773},{"src":771},{"label":1666},"Reinforcement Learning",{"name":777,"url":778},{"title":234,"description":1658},"fXiDA8SJAaDJ2rxywcBHv3K9KEZt_Yq5AWkhVF6SHBw",1794600584735]